This
review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained
therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to
copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions.
Crossposted at WordPress, Blogspot & Librarything by Bookstooge’s
Exalted Permission
Title: Dune Messiah
Title: Dune Messiah
Series:
Dune Chronicles #2
Author:
Frank Herbert
Rating:
4.5 of 5 Stars
Genre:
SF
Pages:
340
Format:
Digital Edition
|
Synopsis: |
Paul Atreides is Emperor of the Galaxy. His Fremen have swept planets under his rule and nobody can stop him. For Paul can see the future and how do you fight a man who can see THAT? The answer appears to be, very carefully and with layers upon layers of plots.
The Bene Gesserit, the Spacing Guild,
the Bene Tleilax and Princess Irulan are all in to bring the downfall
of Paul Atreides, who seems to be on the cusp of attaining godhood.
They attack his family through Chani. They subvert his Quizarate.
They foment rebellion amongst the Naibs who cannot deal with the
rapid change of climate on Dune. They tempt Paul himself with the
gola of Duncan Idaho, the man who gave his life to save Paul.
And Paul sees this all and knows this
all and he doesn't know how to stop seeing the future. He is walking
a path of least resistance, the smallest amount of chaos but as the
Navigators found out in Dune, that
eventually leads to Stagnation. So Paul lets the future happen and
hopes that his children can somehow change things.
And as
a blind Fremen, he walks out into the desert to die.
|
My Thoughts:
|
Some seriously wicked crazy plotting going on here. Not everyone is happy with Emperor Paul. In fact, most of the power groups aren't. We get introduced to the Bene Tleilax, a group/race of people that are, in essence, shapechangers. They can also mimic those they change into. The Bene Gesserit are upset because their little breeding program is off the rails; what's the point of creating a superman if you can't control him? The Spacing Guild, CHOAM and the Landsraad are all pretty put out as Paul exercises supreme authority and they have to do what they're told.
I
really liked how Herbert figures out a way to make it possible to
blind someone who can see the future. If nothing else in this book
impresses you, the fact that Herbert doesn't make Paul unassailable
should make you re-read Dune with
new eyes.
There
was a lot of philosophy talk being thrown around. There was a lot of
political machinations going on. This had nuances and creases and
folds that were not only not apparent in Dune, but
were pretty much unthinkable. Herbert completely throws Paul under
the bus because that is the only place he can go.
Alia
plays the second biggest role here, in my opinion. She's not quite as
powerful as Paul and is constantly trying to catch up to her big
brother. That isn't very ominous until you're doing a Re-Read. Then
it becomes the scary music in the background. In many ways it seems
that Paul does nothing to try to stop her. But that is a “thing”
for him. He is hemmed in by prophecy of future sight and so he is so
afraid of meddling with others and somehow damaging their free will.
Free
will is about having the choice. Not all the choices, not clearly
spelled out, not with all the knowledge of the consequences. Free
Will means being able to say “yes” or “no” to something. Even
while bemoaning the future sight, Paul still had Free Will. He just
didn't want to face the consequences of taking a different path and
so he didn't.
And so
like in our world, one generation of heroes must make way for
another.
★★★★ ½
No comments:
Post a Comment