This
review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained
therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to
copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions.
Crossposted at WordPress & Blogspot by Bookstooge’s Exalted
Permission
Title:
The Shadow of Doctor Syn
Series: Doctor Syn
#7
Author: Arthur Russell Thorndike
Rating:
3 of 5 Stars
Genre: Historical Fiction
Pages:
177
Words: 83K
This
was a good end to the Scarecrow/Dr Syn series. The action and the
smuggler scenes were just as enjoyable as ever. Sadly, The Scarecrow
in France during The Terror is only a tiny part, but he does make a
complete fool of Robespierre, so I was happy with what I got.
My biggest gripe, and what prevented this from being 3.5stars, was the infernal romance story. Yet another daughter of Dr Syn’s best friend Tony falls in love with him, with quite predictable results. That Dr Syn, he’s just got ZERO chance with women. His wife cheats on him and runs off. His second fiance is killed while pretending to be the Scarecrow and so of course, the younger sister also dies while pretending to be the Scarecrow. It does remind me of the whole Age Gap thing in romances. I’ve talked about this in other books (namely Jane Austen’s books) and don’t feel the need to rehash the whole thing. BUT. At this point in time, Dr Syn is in his mid to late 40’s and Cicily is either 17 or 19. That is a MUCH bigger age gap than even Marianne and Col. Brandon in Sense and Sensibility. I didn’t honestly see how it was going to work. The author makes it work by making Dr Syn pretty much be the same person he was in his 20’s. While he’s had all these experiences, they didn’t change him, and they should have. No offense to any teens who might read this, but you’re all a bunch of muffinheads to be honest and being married to a teenager at my age would be its own special brand of heck. The author just cheated and used the “Love conquers all” trope so he could shoehorn in a romance subplot. But it was awkward and since I read the first book first, well, I knew Dr Syn was single then, so Cicily had to go one way or another.
The cover is ridiculous. It’s a great cover, but it’s still ridiculous. Dr Syn is very careful to keep his shirt on because of a tattoo that would prove he was Captain Clegg the notorious pirate. And him being next to the guillotine, well, I addressed that earlier. But it sure is eye catching and garish, just what you want to sell a book!
Overall, the fact that I finished this series when I wasn’t sure near the beginning means it was enjoyable enough to keep me hooked despite my issues with treating the clergy like an unbeliever.
★★★☆☆
From Wikipedia
Set in 1793 during the events of the French Revolution, Syn travels to France amidst the Reign of Terror. He has fallen in love with young Cicily Cobtree and hopes his actions against Robespierre will earn him a pardon from the King. When Cicily dies, Syn gives up his ideas of pardon and nearly loses his sanity. This sets the stage for the fiendish character he becomes in Doctor Syn: A Tale of the Romney Marsh.