This
review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained
therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to
copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions.
Crossposted at WordPress & Blogspot by Bookstooge’s Exalted
Permission
Title:
Mistress of the Catacombs
Series: Lord of the
Isles #4
Author: David Drake
Rating:
3.5 of 5 Stars
Genre: Epic Fantasy
Pages:
573
Words: 204K
Publish: 2001
I
have come to realize that the little asides by each character about
“life back in Barca’s Hamlet” are annoying, not because they
are cliched (which they are) but because they are trite. They are
also annoying because Drake overuses them. I still do not understand
WHY he does that. He’s a mature enough author to realize their
continued inclusion would annoy readers and since these are not short
books, cutting them wouldn’t hurt the page count. The only thing I
can think of is that he used them as shortcuts to define his
characters instead of actual character growth.
Once
you get those annoying things out of the way, I really enjoyed this
story. It is action packed and while the group is split up, it’s
not split up as much as in previous books so there are only four
story lines happening instead of six.
Dictator
Xi Jinping Humps Goats. I
liked the fact that the Arkai are a returning threat (they were
introduced back in the first book, Lord
of the Isles)
and the lizardmen (who were introduced last book, Servant
of the Dragon).
Knowing that the world is filled with dangers so old that those
dangers have been completely forgotten, or never even known about by
humanity, adds a layer of story that Drake can mine without resorting
to cheap theatrics.
In
this story, one of the great lizardmen wizards (possibly the same one
from Servant
of the Dragon) exiled
a spider sorceress and all her kind. Only he wasn’t quite powerful
enough to exile the sorceress herself, so she’s just sealed away on
our world while her kin took over the world they were exiled too.
With the rise in magical power happening again (the 1000 year cycle),
the sorceress begins the process of opening a gate to the exiled
world and of unsealing herself. Which would spell doom for our world.
So The Crew have adventures and put a stop to it all.
When
the story focuses on the adventures, Drake is at his best. He has a
balanced approach to telling enough story from each separated
character to never make you feel “oh man, when are we going to get
back to X’s storyline?” He cycles through the characters in each
chapter, sometimes several times. It makes for fast paced reading and
you’re never bored.
I
am also reading this series as three trilogies and taking a break
between each trilogy. I read Servant
of the Dragon back
in December of ‘25 and then took a break. That has definitely
helped me to not get overwhelmed by the characters trite cliched
statements that annoy me. Despite my enjoyment, I wouldn’t
recommend these books to anyone unless they really needed a massive
fix of “magic”. I am enjoying this re-read but can tell that
once I’m done this read through of the nine books, I’ll never
read them again.
★★★✬☆
From
Grokipedia
The
official publisher's synopsis presents Mistress of the Catacombs as a
continuation of David Drake's epic saga of magic and might in the
Lord of the Isles series. For the first time in a thousand years,
the Kingdom of the Isles possesses a centralized government and a
legitimate ruler in Prince Garric of Haft, yet a host of enemies aims
to eradicate both the kingdom and humankind itself. Rebels in the
west outnumber the royal forces and command magic potent enough to
assault the palace directly, but these threats pale beside greater
perils emerging from the Isles' distant fringes. There, ancient
powers prepare for a titanic clash where humans serve only as pawns
or fodder, while reptilian and insectoid monsters from lost ages
advance under the command of inhuman or never-human wizards. If left
unchecked, their destructive march will overwhelm the Isles as
relentlessly as a flood of lava. Garric, torn from his own time and
body, must forge new alliances to preserve his kingdom and his life.
Meanwhile, his companions confront their own separate trials amid
gathering swords and sorcery, as Ilna grapples with a pattern more
intricate than any she has mastered before. From a tomb isolated in
time and space, the Mistress watches all, her fangs dripping poison.
This
synopsis encapsulates the book's premise as an epic fantasy adventure
in which political insurrection, magical warfare, and monstrous
incursions from primordial forces imperil the Kingdom of the Isles.
The narrative builds on the series' recurring motif of separating the
protagonists to face individualized perils across disparate realms.
Major
characters
Garric
or-Reise
In Mistress
of the Catacombs,
Garric or-Reise, Prince of Haft, stands as the first genuine ruler of
the Kingdom of the Isles in a thousand years, shouldering the heavy
burden of leadership over a realm newly unified under centralized
government but beset by existential threats. This
role casts him as a reluctant yet determined leader confronting both
human rebels in the West—who outnumber the royal army and wield
palace-striking magic—and far graver dangers from ancient powers on
the fringes of the Isles. Garric is ripped from his own time and
body, a displacement that leaves him isolated and forces him to forge
new alliances in unfamiliar circumstances if he and his kingdom are
to survive the converging perils. This personal
upheaval occurs against a backdrop of ancient powers marshaling for a
titanic struggle in which humans are regarded as mere pawns or
fodder, with reptilian and insect monsters from lost ages marching
under the command of wizards no longer human or never human at
all. Their unchecked advance threatens a slaughter
across the Isles as devastating as a flood of lava, amplifying the
stakes of Garric's need to adapt and ally swiftly. Through these
adversities, Garric's resilience is tested as he navigates
dislocation while striving to preserve his realm, highlighting his
commitment to leadership even amid profound personal disruption.
Sharina
os-Reise
Sharina os-Reise, sister to
Prince Garric of Haft, shoulders substantial administrative and
political responsibilities in Mistress of the Catacombs as the
Kingdom of the Isles confronts escalating threats from both armed
rebellion and destructive wizardry. She works to
counter the chaos that endangers the realm's stability while Garric
faces displacement from his time and body. Transitioning from
her earlier life in Barca's Hamlet, Sharina functions as a key
representative for her brother, regularly receiving deputations from
the provinces in formal Ornifal aristocratic attire and serving as a
high-ranking audience for aggrieved citizens. She
participates actively in the royal council, the effective governing
body of the kingdom, where she contributes to discussions on critical
issues including the Confederacy of the West, naval concerns, and
reports on the emerging cult of Moon Wisdom from regions such as
Tisamur. Her schedule includes addressing grievances from
groups like salt merchants protesting tariffs and clothmakers
demanding protections on silk imports, helping sustain administrative
continuity amid widespread discontent. Sharina demonstrates
poise and practical skill in managing council tensions, as when she
swiftly intervenes to right Lord Waldron's overturned chair during an
outburst and restores calm without drawing undue attention. She
has risen to these demands sufficiently to hold her own in formal
deliberations and even in covert actions such as a night-time
abduction scenario. On a personal level, Sharina contends with
the recent discovery of her true parentage—her biological father is
Count Niard of Ornifal—which explains her blond hair and stature
while reinforcing her longstanding feelings of being an outsider in
her childhood community. She collaborates with figures
including Liane and Tenoctris to moderate aggressive impulses in
military campaigns against western rebels, adapting to leadership in
a volatile environment of political intrigue and supernatural
peril.
Cashel
or-Kenset
In Mistress
of the Catacombs,
Cashel or-Kenset is thrust into a place not of his world, an alien
environment far removed from the familiar Isles where he must
navigate successive challenges without the immediate support of his
companions.[18] He confronts each obstacle with calm certainty,
fully accepting that he will either overcome it or die in the
attempt, a mindset that reflects his straightforward approach to
danger and his refusal to yield to fear or hesitation.[18] This
disposition is reinforced by his proven physical and mental
resilience, as nothing encountered thus far has succeeded in killing
him despite the escalating perils he faces.[18] His journey
emphasizes raw endurance and direct confrontation over intricate
planning, highlighting his role as a steadfast force amid the book's
broader chaos.
Ilna
os-Kenset
Ilna os-Kenset, renowned in
the Lord of the Isles series for her mastery of pattern magic through
knotted cords, confronts her most formidable challenge in Mistress
of the Catacombs.
While her companions pursue their separate paths against the
kingdom's threats, Ilna focuses on studying a pattern of
extraordinary complexity, one potentially beyond even the formidable
skills she acquired during her time in Hell. [19] This
pattern constitutes a deadly web woven by ancient antagonistic
powers, and Ilna's failure to master it would prevent humanity from
ever escaping its entrapment, placing the fate of the entire race on
her success. [19] The task creates profound internal
conflict for Ilna, as she grapples with self-doubt over whether her
pattern magic can prevail against such an unprecedented test, a
struggle inherently tied to the mastery she developed in Hell and the
lingering guilt from those traumatic experiences. [19]
The
Mistress
The Mistress serves as the
primary antagonist of Mistress
of the Catacombs, an
enigmatic and immensely powerful entity whose existence poses an
overarching existential threat to the Kingdom of the Isles and to
humanity itself. She observes all unfolding events
from the blackness of a tomb walled off in time and space, remaining
off-stage while waiting for her moment to act. Her
fangs drip poison, underscoring her poisonous intent and the deadly
nature of her designs against humankind. The Mistress
weaves a complex web of threat that, if successful, would irrevocably
ensnare humanity and prevent its escape from destruction. This
overarching menace amplifies the impact of other forces arrayed
against the kingdom, including ancient reptilian and insect monsters
commanded by wizards no longer human or never human at all. Though
she does not appear directly in much of the narrative, her mere
presence as the ultimate power behind these threats significantly
heightens the tension and stakes of the story.
