This
review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained
therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to
copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions.
Crossposted at WordPress & Blogspot by Bookstooge’s Exalted
Permission
Title:
Guards! Guards!
Series: Discworld #8
Author:
Terry Pratchett
Rating: 4 of 5 Stars
Genre:
Fantasy
Pages: 259
Words: 98K
One
hundred percent better than when I read this back in 2007 (link at
the bottom of the review). A lot of that is that I’ve read enough
of Discworld to know now that it’s not all madcap silliness, like I
was expecting back then. It also helps that I’m reading these in
publication order and keeps me from getting tunnel vision on one set
of characters (Rincewind, the Witches, Death, etc) and hitting a wall
when a book is about a different set. I am really liking reading
these this way because it feels more well rounded and Discworld as a
setting is fleshed out more by the various characters instead of
being seen from just one perspective.
I
had forgotten just how broken Vimes is at the beginning. In many ways
this is a redemption story and yet, it’s not. I can’t put my
finger on it exactly, but part of it is more about Vimes himself
pulling himself up by the bootstraps than any redemption. Vimes (for
some reason I always want to say “Grimes”) is a very humanistic
literary character and I can see why Pratchett chose to create him
and why many readers of Discworld identify with him. There’s
nothing of the supernatural intruding into Vime’s life to make him
question life’s basic questions. There’s just crime and grime and
apathy. He can overcome those things on his own with no help (as thus
enable the reader to feel that they can too). I have a feeling that
is one of the reasons I didn’t care for The Watch sub-series as
much before.
I
still don’t like that direction, but having interacted a lot more
with people of no faith in the last 17 years has given me a broader
and hopefully more sympathetic feeling towards those who would feel
like Vimes does. They are wrong, but I’m not so likely to shake my
finger at them and lecture them for 30 min. I cut that down to just
10 minutes now ;-)
The
story was fun. Rogue magic user politician wannabe takes over the
city and gets in WAY over his head. Vimes and the Night Watch help
figure things out while the Patrician sits back and lets things play
out. It was a relatively light story with only Ankh-Morpork at stake
and not the whole of Discworld. Grimes, blast it, Vimes, has enough
Everyman Banal Thoughts to make those not used to thinking for
themselves feel like they are reading something deep while the rest
of us can safely roll our eyes and think about kicking Vimes in the
pants to get him out of his funk.
Now
that I’ve read the first of The Watch books again and enjoyed it so
much, I am looking forward to the rest of them. I really wasn’t
before, but I think that reading the books in publication order is
going to continue to make a night and day difference for me.
Cheers
to that!
★★★★☆
From
Wikipedia.org
A
secret monastic order plots to overthrow
the Patrician of Ankh-Morpork and install
a puppet monarch under the control of the Order. They
summon a dragon to terrorise the city and plan to have the
puppet "slay" the dragon and claim to be the lost heir of
the defunct royal house.
The
Night Watch, which is generally seen as both corrupt and incompetent,
starts to change with the arrival of idealistic new recruit Carrot
Ironfoundersson, a human orphan raised by dwarfish parents. When
the Librarian of the Unseen University (an orangutan)
reports a book of magic stolen, Vimes links the theft to the dragon's
appearances. The Watch's investigation makes the acquaintance of Lady
Sybil Ramkin, who breeds small swamp dragons, and gives an
underdeveloped dragon named Errol to the Watch as a mascot.
At
first, the plot works flawlessly. The Patrician is ousted in favor of
the new king, but the banished dragon returns and makes itself king,
demanding gold and virgin sacrifices, and
prepares to wage war against Ankh-Morpork's neighbours for the
further acquisition of both (which the citizenry generally seem to
approve of).
Vimes
confronts his old childhood friend, the Patrician's Secretary Lupine
Wonse, having figured out that he is the Supreme Grand Master, and
responsible for the dragon's appearance. Vimes is imprisoned in the
same cell as the Patrician. Vimes escapes with the help of the
Librarian and runs to rescue Sybil, chosen as the first sacrificed
maiden. After the remaining Watch fail to kill the king through a
'million-to-one chance' arrowshot, Errol fights it, and knocks it
from the sky. The assembled crowd closes in to kill the king, and
Sybil pleads for the dragon's life. Carrot arrests it, but Errol lets
it escape. The dragon is in fact female, and the battle between them
was a courtship ritual.
Vimes
arrests Wonse, as he tries to summon another dragon, telling Carrot
to "throw the book at him". Wonse falls to his death after
the very literal Carrot hits him with a thrown copy of Laws and
Ordinances of Ankh-Morpork.
The
Patrician is reinstated as ruler of Ankh-Morpork, and offers the
Watch anything they want as a reward. They ask only for a modest pay
raise, a new tea kettle, and a dartboard. However, since the Watch's
original station house was destroyed by the dragon, Lady Ramkin
donates her childhood home at Pseudopolis Yard to serve as the new
one.